Cruizer, though I feel you are trying to disagree just to disagree, I will agree with one point you made - RC should be the one to enforce their own rules. The problem is, most times they do not. Why bother posting "suggested attire" when you are not going to enforce it, right? So when you walk down to the dining room on formal night and NOT dressed formally, hopefully they will adhere to their own suggestions and remind you of the excellent repast in the Windjammer and suggest dining there because you are not dressed appropriately. That would be fair to all. It's fair to me because I would be dressed appropriately for formal night, and also fair to you because you choose not to, even though it is the suggested form of attire. Like I said, water under the bridge. Let's move on.