Two ships, same line, #2 though would be about $400-500 more all told (which is about 17% more expensive or so). Itenary1 - Grand Cayman. Cozumel. Belize. Isla Roatan. Itenary2 - San Juan Puerto Rico, St Thomas, St Maarten. I've been to both Grand Cayman and Cozumel before (and loved both), but have never been to the other ports. I am interested from those who have, which sounds the better itenary to you? Are there any ports there that you would rather miss, or ones that are "don't miss" types? I'm not a first time cruiser, but I am a relative novice still. I appreciate any input!